A Very Law Victory Demonstrates Creative Advocacy and Unwavering Determination

The idea of losing a beloved dog in a divorce or separation is unthinkable. For many people, their dogs are four-legged family members who greet us at the door, comfort us on hard days, and share in our daily routines. 

Unfortunately, under Pennsylvania law, dogs are classified as personal property. In the eyes of the law, they’re no different from any asset – one that can be taken during divorce proceedings. 

That is exactly the legal challenge one of our clients recently faced. Thanks to the exceptional skill and determination of Very Law attorney Vinnie, they walked away with something Pennsylvania courts rarely grant: an enforceable court order for dog custody.

The Problem: Pennsylvania Does Not Recognize Pet Custody

When couples go through a contested divorce or separation in Pennsylvania, disputes over shared pets can become emotionally devastating. Unlike child custody cases, where Pittsburgh custody lawyers can argue based on the best interests of the child, Pennsylvania law offers no such framework for pets. Dogs, cats, and other companion animals are treated as marital property subject to equitable distribution.

Pet custody in PA isn’t as simple as determining who has the stronger emotional bond or who can provide a better living situation. Instead, the court considers documented evidence, such as who purchased the pet, whose name appears on veterinary records, or who paid for food and supplies.

This is a cold approach to the welfare of a furry friend. After all, you cannot split a dog in half the way you might divide a savings account based on who contributed to it. This is why states like Alaska, California, Illinois, and most recently, Rhode Island have started making changes to how pet ownership is handled in divorce proceedings. They’ve enacted statutes requiring courts to consider the "best interest" of the pet when determining custody.

Pennsylvania has yet to follow suit. However, recent legislative efforts suggest changes to pet custody laws may be on the horizon.

A Creative Approach to an Unfavorable Legal Landscape

When our client came to Very Law seeking help, the situation appeared bleak. The law did not recognize their claim to custody, and traditional legal avenues seemed closed. But Vinnie refused to accept that outcome.

Drawing on his experience, his understanding of Pennsylvania family law, and his commitment to achieving favorable outcomes, Vinnie identified a creative legal strategy to pursue an enforceable custody arrangement. 

Interestingly, this arrangement takes a page from what proposed legislation would allow in future divorce proceedings. Staying ahead of the curve, Vinnie pushed forward a groundbreaking strategy that could affect future cases. If the law is eventually enacted, his case will pave the way for many future pet owners and their divorce attorneys – as well as many others in general property disputes where his ideas can also apply. 

This outcome is a testament to what dedicated legal representation can accomplish even when the law appears unfavorable. It reflects the values that define our Pittsburgh family law practice: creative problem-solving, tireless advocacy, and a genuine commitment to our clients' well-being.

Why This Case of Pet Custody in PA Goes Beyond One Client

This victory is about more than one family and one dog. It highlights a gap in Pennsylvania law that affects countless pet owners navigating separation and divorce. Pets provide emotional support – and in the midst of a contentious divorce, their companionship cannot be overstated. This is why the law should reflect the role it plays in our lives.

At Very Law, we believe in advocating not just for individual clients but for positive change in the legal system. We support efforts to modernize Pennsylvania's approach to pet custody, bringing it in line with similar pet custody laws in states that already recognize pets as more than property.

If you are facing a custody dispute – whether it involves children, pets, or both – know that you do not have to navigate it alone. Our family law attorneys understand that every family looks different, and we are prepared to fight for what matters most to you.

When the Law Says No, We Find a Way

Vinnie's success is a powerful reminder that the right attorney can make all the difference in your case. When you are told the law does not support your case, you need a legal team willing to dig deeper, think creatively, and advocate fiercely on your behalf.

That is the Very Law difference.

If you are facing a family law matter and want an attorney who will fight for you, schedule a strategy session with our team today.